- The title is a reference to the nursery rhyme Peter, Peter, Pumpkin Eater, which was previously referenced in "Peter, Peter, Caviar Eater".
- Patrick McCloskey says "Forget it Peter, it's Pumpkintown," referencing the film Chinatown.
Previous Episode's References /// Peter, Peter, Pumpkin Cheater's References \\\ Next Episode's References
| << Season 22 | Family Guy Season 23 | ||||||||||
| #01 | Peter, Peter, Pumpkin Cheater | #09 | Pitch Imperfect | #17 | The One with All the Abortions | ||||||
| #02 | Gift of the White Guy | #10 | The Butterfly Erect | #18 | Double Annul | ||||||
| #03 | Live, Laugh, Love | #11 | The Elle Word | #19 | The Fat Lotus | ||||||
| #04 | Drunk with Power | #12 | A Real Who's Hulu | #20 | The Edible Arrangement | ||||||
| #05 | Lois C.K. | #13 | China Doll | #21 | Twain's World | ||||||
| #06 | Fat Gun | #14 | One Foot in Front of the Mother | #22 | Pumpkin Spice Girls | ||||||
| #07 | The Chicken or the Meg | #15 | TBA | #23 | Young Carter | ||||||
| #08 | Dog is My Co-Pilot | #16 | Martian Meg | #24 | Lyin' Brian |
| |||||
| Order subject to change | |||||||||||